When it comes to removing makeup effectively, cleansing balms stand out for their gentle yet thorough cleansing ability. The e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm offers a budget-friendly option that works well for most skin types, while the ELEMIS Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm is a luxurious choice for those seeking a multi-benefit skincare product. The main tradeoffs involve balancing price, texture, and additional skin benefits—more affordable options may lack some skincare nutrients, and premium balms often come with a higher price tag. Continue reading for a detailed comparison of these and other top picks to find the best fit for your makeup removal routine.
Get ready for Prime Big Deal Days — try Prime free
Exclusive member deals on October 6–7, plus fast free delivery. Cancel anytime.
Start your free trialAs an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
Complete the kit
Key Takeaways
- The best cleansing balms combine effective makeup removal with skin-nourishing ingredients.
- Texture and ease of use vary widely, influencing how comfortable they are for daily use.
- Some balms include added skincare benefits like hydration or anti-aging properties, but these often come at a higher cost.
- Fragrance-free options are preferred for sensitive skin, though they may be less aromatic.
- Size and value are key considerations; larger jars offer better value but may be less convenient for travel.
| e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm JUMBO |  | Best Value for Hydrated, All-Skin-Types Makeup Removal | Size: 3.5 Oz | Infused with: Hyaluronic Acid, Ceramides, Peptides | Formulation: Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Leaping Bunny Certified | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| ELEMIS Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm, 3-in-1 Hydrating Facial Cleanser |  | Best for Gentle, Multi-Use Cleansing and Hydration | Type: Cleansing Balm | Size: 3 oz | Infused Ingredients: Lavender, Chamomile, Eucalyptus, Elderberry, Starflower, Optimega Oils | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Clinique Take The Day Off Cleansing Balm Makeup Remover |  | Best for Sensitive Skin and Eye Makeup Removal | Type: Balm-to-oil | Skin Type: All skin types | Fragrance-Free: Yes | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Neutrogena Makeup Remover Melting Balm, Fragrance-Free, 2 oz |  | Best Travel-Friendly Fragrance-Free Makeup Remover | Size: 2 oz | Fragrance-Free: Yes | Suitable for: All skin types, Sensitive skin | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| BANILA CO Clean It Zero Original Cleansing Balm Big Size |  | Best for Waterproof and Long-Wear Makeup Removal | Size: 6.08 fl oz | Type: Balm to Oil Cleanser | Ingredients: Acerola berry, Vitamin C | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| Dr. Althea Pure Grinding Cleansing Balm, Korean Vegan Skin Care, 1.69 Fl Oz |  | Best Hygienic Innovation | Volume: 1.69 Fl Oz | Skin Type: All skin types | Features: Hygienic grinding mechanism, one-step cleanser, hydrating, gentle | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm, 2 oz |  | Best Hydrating Melter | Size: 2 oz | Infused with: Hyaluronic acid, ceramides, peptides | Suitable for: All skin types | VIEW ON AMAZON | See Our Full Breakdown |
| cleansing balms for makeup | Size |
|---|---|
| e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration! Ma | 3.5 Oz |
| ELEMIS Pro-Collagen Cleansing | 3 oz |
| Clinique Take The Day Off Clea | — |
| Neutrogena Makeup Remover Melt | 2 oz |
| BANILA CO Clean It Zero Origin | 6.08 fl oz |
| Dr. Althea Pure Grinding Clean | — |
| e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration! Ma | 2 oz |
More Details on Our Top Picks
e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm JUMBO
This jumbo-sized balm stands out for offering excellent value due to its large 3.5 oz amount, making it ideal for those who want an affordable, effective makeup remover that nourishes skin. Its solid balm melts into a nourishing oil and milk texture, infused with hyaluronic acid, ceramides, and peptides—ingredients that support skin hydration and barrier health. Compared with the smaller e.l.f. Holy Hydration! Balm, this version’s bigger size makes it more cost-effective for frequent use, especially for those with dry or sensitive skin. The main tradeoff is that solid balms like this may require warming up before application, which could be inconvenient for some. It’s best suited for budget-conscious users seeking a nourishing, all-in-one makeup remover and cleanser.
Pros:- Large size offers great value for frequent use
- Infused with hydrating and skin barrier-supporting ingredients
- Effective at melting away makeup and leaving skin silky
Cons:- Solid balm may need warming for easier application
- Some users might prefer a liquid or gel format for convenience
Best for: Budget-conscious individuals who want a large, nourishing cleansing balm suitable for all skin types
Not ideal for: People preferring liquid cleansers or those who dislike warming solid balms before use
- Size:3.5 Oz
- Infused with:Hyaluronic Acid, Ceramides, Peptides
- Formulation:Vegan, Cruelty-Free, Leaping Bunny Certified
Our verdict“This balm is perfect for those seeking an affordable, nourishing makeup remover in a generous size.”
ELEMIS Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm, 3-in-1 Hydrating Facial Cleanser
This product excels at providing a gentle yet effective cleanse, especially for those who want a versatile balm that can double as a weekly mask. Its botanical oil infusion makes it soothing and nourishing, ideal for sensitive or mature skin. Unlike the Clinique balm, which transforms into an oil, the ELEMIS formula remains more of a soft balm that can be massaged in for hydration or rinsed off for a clean feel. It’s a good choice for users who prefer natural ingredients and multi-purpose skincare routines but may require a cloth for removal, adding an extra step. Price-wise, it’s a premium option, better suited to those willing to invest in a luxurious, botanical-based cleanser.
Pros:- Gentle, botanical-infused formula
- Multi-purpose use as a daily cleanser or weekly mask
- Hydrates skin while cleansing
Cons:- Requires a cloth or rinse for complete removal
- Higher price point compared to drugstore options
Best for: Individuals with sensitive, mature, or dry skin seeking a nourishing, multi-use cleansing balm
Not ideal for: People looking for an affordable or quick-rinse balm, or those preferring a no-fuss cleansing routine
- Type:Cleansing Balm
- Size:3 oz
- Infused Ingredients:Lavender, Chamomile, Eucalyptus, Elderberry, Starflower, Optimega Oils
- Use:Daily cleanser or weekly facial mask
- Formula:Mineral oil-free
Our verdict“This balm suits those prioritizing gentle, botanical hydration with versatile application options.”
Clinique Take The Day Off Cleansing Balm Makeup Remover
This lightweight balm is distinguished by its gentle, hypoallergenic formulation that melts into an oil, making it especially suitable for sensitive skin and delicate eye makeup. Compared to the e.l.f. jumbo balm, Clinique’s product is more refined and designed specifically for sensitive and eye areas, but it might require thorough rinsing to ensure all residue is gone, unlike some balms that simply wipe away. Its effectiveness at removing makeup, sunscreens, and pollutants makes it a solid choice for users with sensitive or reactive skin. However, the need for rinsing can add an extra step, and it’s less bulky than larger, more economical balms.
Pros:- Effective at removing makeup and sunscreen
- Gentle and suitable for sensitive skin and eyes
- Transforms from balm to oil for thorough cleansing
Cons:- May require thorough rinsing to remove all residue
- Less effective on very heavy or waterproof makeup alone
Best for: People with sensitive or reactive skin, or those who wear eye makeup daily and need a gentle remover
Not ideal for: Users seeking a budget-friendly, large-volume cleansing balm or those preferring no-rinse options
- Type:Balm-to-oil
- Skin Type:All skin types
- Fragrance-Free:Yes
- Hypoallergenic:Yes
Our verdict“Ideal for sensitive skin users who prioritize gentle, effective eye makeup removal without irritation.”
Neutrogena Makeup Remover Melting Balm, Fragrance-Free, 2 oz
This small, fragrance-free balm offers a convenient option for travelers and sensitive skin users, with a solid-to-oil transformation that effectively dissolves all makeup, including stubborn eye and lip products. Compared with larger balms like BANILA CO, it’s more portable, making it ideal for on-the-go use. Its gentle, fragrance-free formula appeals to sensitive skin, but the smaller size means you’ll need to restock more frequently if used regularly. The solid-to-oil consistency might take some getting used to, and it may require rinsing or follow-up cleansing for complete removal, especially on heavier makeup days.
Pros:- Travel-friendly size
- Fragrance-free and gentle for sensitive skin
- Effective at removing all traces of makeup
Cons:- Requires rinsing or additional cleansing for complete removal
- Small size may necessitate frequent repurchasing
Best for: Travelers and sensitive skin users who need a compact, effective makeup remover
Not ideal for: Those with heavy or waterproof makeup who prefer a more robust, larger balm for a single-step cleanse
- Size:2 oz
- Fragrance-Free:Yes
- Suitable for:All skin types, Sensitive skin
Our verdict“This balm is well-suited for travel and sensitive skin but may fall short for heavy makeup removal in a single step.”
BANILA CO Clean It Zero Original Cleansing Balm Big Size
This award-winning, large-sized balm is recognized for its sherbet-to-oil formula that effectively melts away waterproof makeup and long-wear products. Compared with the Neutrogena balm, it provides more capacity for regular use, making it ideal for those with heavy makeup routines. While it hydrates and cleanses without stripping moisture, it does require a separate step with a foaming cleanser to fully remove stubborn residues, which can be a minor inconvenience. Its ability to handle waterproof and long-wear makeup makes it a reliable choice for users with demanding makeup needs, but it might be less convenient for quick, minimalist routines.
Pros:- Excellent at removing waterproof and long-wear makeup
- Hydrates and leaves skin soft
- Large size offers good value for frequent use
Cons:- Requires a separate cleanser for stubborn residue
- Less effective on very heavy or long-wear makeup alone
Best for: Makeup users who wear waterproof, long-wear, or heavy makeup daily and need a reliable remover
Not ideal for: People seeking an all-in-one, no-rinse cleansing solution or with very sensitive, reactive skin
- Size:6.08 fl oz
- Type:Balm to Oil Cleanser
- Ingredients:Acerola berry, Vitamin C
- Vegan:Yes
- Hypoallergenic:Yes
- Dermatologist Tested:Yes
Our verdict“This balm fits makeup enthusiasts with waterproof or long-lasting products who need a dependable, large-capacity remover.”
Dr. Althea Pure Grinding Cleansing Balm, Korean Vegan Skin Care, 1.69 Fl Oz
This cleansing balm stands out for its hygienic grinding mechanism, which minimizes contact with hands and enhances cleanliness, making it a particularly appealing choice for those concerned about contamination. Compared to the e.l.f. Holy Hydration! balm, which relies on traditional scooping, the grinding system ensures a fresher experience and precise dosage. However, first-time users may need to adjust to the mechanism, and the price is somewhat higher than standard balms. Its nourishing blend of plant-based oils and Madecassoside not only effectively removes waterproof makeup and sunscreen but also leaves skin feeling hydrated and soothed. This pick is ideal for users who prioritize hygiene and want a gentle, nourishing cleanser that can handle stubborn makeup. Conversely, those on a tight budget or seeking a quick, no-fuss option might find this less practical.
Pros:- Hygienic grinding mechanism minimizes contamination risk
- Effective at removing waterproof makeup, sunscreen, and heavy products
- Nourishes skin with plant-based oils and Madecassoside
Cons:- May require some adjustment to the grinding mechanism initially
- Higher cost compared to traditional cleansing balms
Best for: Individuals prioritizing hygiene and innovative packaging, especially those who wear waterproof makeup regularly
Not ideal for: Budget-conscious buyers or those seeking a quick, simple cleanse without additional features
- Volume:1.69 Fl Oz
- Skin Type:All skin types
- Features:Hygienic grinding mechanism, one-step cleanser, hydrating, gentle
Our verdict“This balm is best suited for users who value hygiene and effective removal of waterproof makeup, willing to invest in a more innovative cleansing experience.”
e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration! Makeup Melting Cleansing Balm, 2 oz
This product makes the most sense for those seeking a hydrating, nourishing balm that melts makeup effortlessly into a silky oil and milk texture, leaving skin feeling moisturized. Compared to the Dr. Althea Pure Grinding Cleansing Balm, which emphasizes hygiene and removal of waterproof makeup, the e.l.f. balm is more straightforward—no special mechanism, just a smooth, effective melt. Its infusion of hyaluronic acid, ceramides, and peptides boosts skin hydration and barrier health, making it ideal for dry or sensitive skin. However, it requires a double cleansing routine for full removal, which might be inconvenient for some. This pick works well for those who prefer a simple, nourishing cleanse and don’t mind a two-step process. It’s less suitable for users who want a quick, single-step removal of heavy waterproof makeup without extra effort.
Pros:- Effectively melts makeup into a silky oil and milk for easy removal
- Hydrating and nourishing with hyaluronic acid, ceramides, and peptides
- Suitable for all skin types, including sensitive skin
Cons:- Requires double cleansing for complete removal, adding extra steps
- Less effective at removing waterproof or heavy-duty makeup in a single pass
Best for: Individuals with dry or sensitive skin who want a nourishing, easy-to-apply makeup remover
Not ideal for: People who prefer a quick, single-step cleansing routine or have oily skin that might need a more mattifying product
- Size:2 oz
- Infused with:Hyaluronic acid, ceramides, peptides
- Suitable for:All skin types
Our verdict“This balm is perfect for those who prioritize hydration and a nourishing feel, accepting a double cleanse as part of their routine.”
How We Picked
These products were evaluated based on their ability to effectively dissolve makeup, especially waterproof formulas, while maintaining skin health. Ease of use, texture, and scent were considered, along with ingredients that benefit or irritate sensitive skin. Value was assessed by size relative to price, and additional skincare features like hydration or anti-aging benefits. The ranking reflects a balance between performance, versatility, and user experience, ensuring options for different budgets and skin types.Factors to Consider When Choosing Cleansing Balms For Makeup
Choosing the right cleansing balm depends on several key factors that influence performance and usability. Beyond basic makeup removal, consider how the product interacts with your skin type, the texture for comfortable application, and additional skincare benefits. Making an informed choice involves weighing these factors against your budget and preferences to find a product that fits seamlessly into your routine.Skin Type Compatibility
It’s essential to select a cleansing balm suited to your skin’s needs. Hydrating formulas with nourishing oils benefit dry or sensitive skin, while those with lightweight, non-comedogenic ingredients work well for oily or acne-prone skin. Fragrance-free options reduce irritation risks for sensitive skin types. Choosing a product that aligns with your skin type can prevent issues like dryness, breakouts, or irritation.
Texture and Ease of Use
The texture influences how easily the balm melts into the skin and how quickly it dissolves makeup. Thicker, denser balms may require more massaging but can be more hydrating, whereas lighter textures are often quicker to rinse away. Consider whether the balm emulsifies easily with water and if it feels comfortable during application — a smooth, non-greasy finish can make daily use more pleasant.
Additional Skincare Benefits
Many cleansing balms now include ingredients like antioxidants, vitamins, or anti-aging compounds, offering extra skincare benefits alongside makeup removal. However, these added features often come with increased cost and may not be necessary for everyone. Balance your desire for multifunctional products with your budget and skin concerns—sometimes a straightforward, effective balm is all you need.
Size, Packaging, and Value
larger jars tend to offer better value per ounce but may be less convenient for travel or quick routines. Packaging that seals tightly helps prevent spoilage, especially for balms with natural oils. Consider how often you’ll use the product and whether a smaller size suffices, or if investing in a larger jar makes sense financially. Always compare price per ounce to gauge true value.
Price Point and Long-term Investment
While premium balms often provide richer textures and added benefits, they come at a higher price point. Budget options can be effective, especially for those who wear makeup less frequently or want a simple solution. If you wear makeup daily or have specific skin concerns, investing in a higher-quality balm might offer better long-term results and comfort. Weigh your budget against your routine’s needs for a balanced choice.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can cleansing balms remove waterproof makeup effectively?
Yes, most high-quality cleansing balms are formulated to dissolve waterproof makeup, which can be more stubborn than regular products. Look for balms that specifically mention waterproof or long-wear makeup removal on their packaging. Proper application—massaging the balm thoroughly and rinsing with warm water—ensures the most effective removal without harsh scrubbing. If you wear waterproof makeup daily, select a balm with proven efficacy in breaking down resistant formulas.
Are fragrance-free balms better for sensitive skin?
Fragrance-free cleansing balms are generally safer choices for sensitive or irritated skin because fragrances can cause allergic reactions or irritation. However, some users may prefer lightly scented products if they tolerate fragrances well. It’s important to check the ingredient list for other potential irritants and opt for balms with soothing, nourishing ingredients like aloe or chamomile if your skin is sensitive.
How often should I use a cleansing balm in my skincare routine?
Most people can use a cleansing balm daily, especially if they wear makeup regularly or prefer a double-cleansing method. Using it twice a day—once in the evening and once in the morning—can help maintain clean, clear skin. Be mindful of your skin’s response; if you notice dryness or irritation, consider reducing frequency or switching to a gentler formula. The key is to find a routine that leaves your skin feeling clean without stripping natural oils.
What should I look for in a cleansing balm if I have oily or acne-prone skin?
For oily or acne-prone skin, choose a lightweight, non-comedogenic balm that won’t clog pores or leave a greasy residue. Look for formulas with ingredients like salicylic acid or tea tree oil if you want added acne-fighting properties. Fragrance-free options are preferable to reduce irritation. Even with these concerns, a gentle yet effective balm can remove makeup without exacerbating oiliness or breakouts.
Is it necessary to rinse off cleansing balms with water?
Yes, rinsing with water is generally recommended after applying a cleansing balm to remove residues and emulsify excess oils. Proper rinsing ensures that no oily film remains, which could clog pores or cause breakouts. Some formulas emulsify well with water, making rinsing quick and easy, while others might require a soft cloth or towel to fully remove. Always follow the instructions on the product for best results.
Conclusion
For those seeking an all-around effective option, the e.l.f. SKIN Holy Hydration! offers great value and versatility, making it ideal for everyday use. If you have sensitive or dry skin, the ELEMIS Pro-Collagen Cleansing Balm provides added nourishment and a luxurious feel, though at a higher cost. Beginners or those on a budget should consider the Neutrogena Makeup Remover Melting Balm, which balances performance with affordability. For premium users or skincare enthusiasts, investing in a product like ELEMIS or BANILA CO could deliver extra benefits. Ultimately, your choice should align with your skin type, budget, and how much you value additional skincare features.Fall yard work Picks
leaf blowers
As an affiliate, we earn on qualifying purchases.
